New Bill of Rights

Polling

The evidence behind the full-spectrum test. For each proposal: support among Democrats, Republicans, and independents, and the proposal's bipartisan floor — the lower of the two parties' support, which is the number we judge a proposal by. Sources are linked wherever they are public; where a poll was commissioned by an advocacy organization, the amendment page says so.

Campaign Finance

Democrats: 84% 84% Dem Republicans: 77% 77% Rep Independents: 74% 74% Ind bipartisan floor · 77% (Republicans)
Ban foreign individuals and entities from spending money to influence ballot initiatives — University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation, 2021
Democrats: 76% 76% Dem Republicans: 71% 71% Rep bipartisan floor · 71% (Republicans)
Limits on the money individuals and organizations can spend on campaigns — Pew Research Center, 2023
Democrats: 88% 88% Dem Republicans: 85% 85% Rep Independents: 84% 84% Ind bipartisan floor · 85% (Republicans)
Requiring dark-money groups to disclose their donors — Brennan Center, 2026
Democrats: 76% 76% Dem Republicans: 72% 72% Rep Independents: 74% 74% Ind bipartisan floor · 72% (Republicans)
Constitutional amendment to regulate and limit money in elections — Ipsos for American Promise, 2025

Term Limits

Democrats: 86% 86% Dem Republicans: 90% 90% Rep bipartisan floor · 86% (Democrats)
Term limits for members of Congress — Pew Research Center, 2023
Democrats: 87% 87% Dem Republicans: 73% 73% Rep Independents: 71% 71% Ind bipartisan floor · 73% (Republicans)
Fixed terms instead of life tenure for Supreme Court justices — Marquette Law School Poll, 2026
Democrats: 80% 80% Dem Republicans: 86% 86% Rep Independents: 84% 84% Ind bipartisan floor · 80% (Democrats)
A term-limits amendment, after hearing both sides' arguments — University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation (deliberative survey), 2023

Ethics

Democrats: 88% 88% Dem Republicans: 87% 87% Rep Independents: 81% 81% Ind bipartisan floor · 87% (Republicans)
Ban members of Congress from trading individual stocks — University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation, 2023
Democrats: 93% 93% Dem Republicans: 88% 88% Rep bipartisan floor · 88% (Republicans)
Enforcing a strict ethics code for Supreme Court justices — Marquette Law School Poll, 2024
Democrats: 90% 90% Dem Republicans: 87% 87% Rep Independents: 82% 82% Ind bipartisan floor · 87% (Republicans)
Extend the stock-trading ban to the President, Vice President, and Supreme Court justices — University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation, 2023
Democrats: 86% 86% Dem Republicans: 62% 62% Rep bipartisan floor · 62% (Republicans)
A binding code of ethics for Supreme Court justices — YouGov, 2024

Privacy

Democrats: 78% 78% Dem Republicans: 68% 68% Rep bipartisan floor · 68% (Republicans)
More government regulation of what companies do with personal data — Pew Research Center, 2023
Democrats: 86% 86% Dem Republicans: 81% 81% Rep bipartisan floor · 81% (Republicans)
Congress should prioritize federal data-protection legislation — Morning Consult, 2023

Lobbying

Democrats: 72% 72% Dem Republicans: 72% 72% Rep bipartisan floor · 72% (Republicans)
Five-year lobbying wait for senior executive-branch officials (acceptable, standalone) — Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland, 2022
Democrats: 74% 74% Dem Republicans: 71% 71% Rep bipartisan floor · 71% (Republicans)
Lifetime ban on former senior officials lobbying for foreign governments — Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland, 2022
Democrats: 67% 67% Dem Republicans: 65% 65% Rep bipartisan floor · 65% (Republicans)
Extend former members of Congress's lobbying wait to at least five years (five-year or lifetime, combined) — Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland, 2022
Democrats: 72% 72% Dem Republicans: 78% 78% Rep bipartisan floor · 72% (Democrats)
Lobbyists have too much influence on Congress — Pew Research Center, 2023

Redistricting

Democrats: 73% 73% Dem Republicans: 70% 70% Rep Independents: 68% 68% Ind bipartisan floor · 70% (Republicans)
Oppose states redrawing congressional districts mid-decade for partisan advantage — Marquette Law School Poll, 2025

Executive Compliance with the Courts

Democrats: 92% 92% Dem Republicans: 78% 78% Rep Independents: 76% 76% Ind bipartisan floor · 78% (Republicans)
A president is required to obey a Supreme Court ruling — Marquette Law School Poll, 2025
Democrats: 95% 95% Dem Republicans: 82% 82% Rep bipartisan floor · 82% (Republicans)
The administration must stop an action the Supreme Court rules illegal — Pew Research Center, 2025
Democrats: 91% 91% Dem Republicans: 65% 65% Rep bipartisan floor · 65% (Republicans)
The administration must obey a ruling by any federal court — Pew Research Center, 2025

Limited Presidential Pardon Reform

Democrats: 88% 88% Dem Republicans: 64% 64% Rep Independents: 77% 77% Ind bipartisan floor · 64% (Republicans)
Presidents should not be able to pardon their own family members — YouGov for Protect Democracy, 2024
Democrats: 76% 76% Dem Republicans: 34% 34% Rep bipartisan floor · 34% (Republicans)
Amend the Constitution to limit the pardon power — Economist/YouGov, 2025
Democrats: 84% 84% Dem Republicans: 50% 50% Rep bipartisan floor · 50% (Republicans)
Presidents should not be able to pardon their staff and associates — YouGov for Protect Democracy, 2024
Democrats: 96% 96% Dem Republicans: 59% 59% Rep Independents: 76% 76% Ind bipartisan floor · 59% (Republicans)
Presidents should not be able to pardon themselves — YouGov for Protect Democracy, 2024

Abolition of the Punishment Exception

Democrats: 85% 85% Dem Republicans: 66% 66% Rep Independents: 69% 69% Ind bipartisan floor · 66% (Republicans)
A state ballot measure ensuring the constitution does not legalize slavery and involuntary servitude as punishments for crime — YouGov, 2024

All numbers

The same data as a table. Click a column heading to sort.

Proposal Amendment Dem Rep Ind Overall Floor Source
Ban foreign individuals and entities from spending money to influence ballot initiatives Campaign Finance 84% 77% 74% 80% 77% (R) University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation (2021)
Limits on the money individuals and organizations can spend on campaigns Campaign Finance 76% 71% 72% 71% (R) Pew Research Center (2023)
Requiring dark-money groups to disclose their donors Campaign Finance 88% 85% 84% 85% 85% (R) Brennan Center (2026)
Constitutional amendment to regulate and limit money in elections Campaign Finance 76% 72% 74% 71% 72% (R) Ipsos for American Promise (2025)
Term limits for members of Congress Term Limits 86% 90% 87% 86% (D) Pew Research Center (2023)
Fixed terms instead of life tenure for Supreme Court justices Term Limits 87% 73% 71% 79% 73% (R) Marquette Law School Poll (2026)
A term-limits amendment, after hearing both sides' arguments Term Limits 80% 86% 84% 83% 80% (D) University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation (deliberative survey) (2023)
Ban members of Congress from trading individual stocks Ethics 88% 87% 81% 86% 87% (R) University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation (2023)
Enforcing a strict ethics code for Supreme Court justices Ethics 93% 88% 90% 88% (R) Marquette Law School Poll (2024)
Extend the stock-trading ban to the President, Vice President, and Supreme Court justices Ethics 90% 87% 82% 87% 87% (R) University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation (2023)
A binding code of ethics for Supreme Court justices Ethics 86% 62% 70% 62% (R) YouGov (2024)
More government regulation of what companies do with personal data Privacy 78% 68% 72% 68% (R) Pew Research Center (2023)
Congress should prioritize federal data-protection legislation Privacy 86% 81% 83% 81% (R) Morning Consult (2023)
Five-year lobbying wait for senior executive-branch officials (acceptable, standalone) Lobbying 72% 72% 71% 72% (R) Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland (2022)
Lifetime ban on former senior officials lobbying for foreign governments Lobbying 74% 71% 71% 71% (R) Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland (2022)
Extend former members of Congress's lobbying wait to at least five years (five-year or lifetime, combined) Lobbying 67% 65% 65% 65% (R) Program for Public Consultation, University of Maryland (2022)
Lobbyists have too much influence on Congress Lobbying 72% 78% 73% 72% (D) Pew Research Center (2023)
Oppose states redrawing congressional districts mid-decade for partisan advantage Redistricting 73% 70% 68% 71% 70% (R) Marquette Law School Poll (2025)
A president is required to obey a Supreme Court ruling Executive Compliance with the Courts 92% 78% 76% 84% 78% (R) Marquette Law School Poll (2025)
The administration must stop an action the Supreme Court rules illegal Executive Compliance with the Courts 95% 82% 88% 82% (R) Pew Research Center (2025)
The administration must obey a ruling by any federal court Executive Compliance with the Courts 91% 65% 78% 65% (R) Pew Research Center (2025)
Presidents should not be able to pardon their own family members Limited Presidential Pardon Reform 88% 64% 77% 77% 64% (R) YouGov for Protect Democracy (2024)
Amend the Constitution to limit the pardon power Limited Presidential Pardon Reform 76% 34% 56% 34% (R) Economist/YouGov (2025)
Presidents should not be able to pardon their staff and associates Limited Presidential Pardon Reform 84% 50% 69% 50% (R) YouGov for Protect Democracy (2024)
Presidents should not be able to pardon themselves Limited Presidential Pardon Reform 96% 59% 76% 78% 59% (R) YouGov for Protect Democracy (2024)
A state ballot measure ensuring the constitution does not legalize slavery and involuntary servitude as punishments for crime Abolition of the Punishment Exception 85% 66% 69% 73% 66% (R) YouGov (2024)

How these numbers are used to accept, hold, or reject a category is described on the mission page; the categories that failed the test are on the rejected categories page.